Try adding a little bit of your preferred mayo (Hellmans for me personally) for this too. You might want to have fun with the quantity however the mayo gives this recipe only the extra push it must have it pretty near to Chick-Fil-A's recipe.
Obviously it should never be perfect nevertheless its close enough for me personally.
It was a great recipe. Pretty near to the original. Used to do tweak it a little though. I elevated the BBQ sauce to at least one Tablespoons of as well as for me that managed to get almost perfect. The next time I'll try adding a little bit of mayo because the other reviewer recommended. That could simply make it 5 stars. Thank you for posting! UPDATE 03/02/2013: I added 1 Tablespoons of of sunshine Hellman's mayonnaise towards the recipe also it was ideal for me!
This sauce, although it jogs my memory, somewhat, from the Chick-Fil-A sauce, it lacks something. The honey mustard is overpowering, as the original sauce is simply perfect. I do not think it is really an exact replica from the Chick-Fil-A sauce, however i think we'll have the ability to use things i made the grandkids should enjoy it.